Monday, January 25, 2010

The Horrific Realities of "Trench Warfare"

The topic of European history has always been of great interest to me, but I have never really had the chance to actually read in-depth accounts of the events that shaped Europe to what it is today. I have always been particularly interested in the topic of the first World War, but never really made any effort into studying the subject. In my high school history class we briefly studied the major events of this conflict, and I knew it was considered one of the ugliest and most brutal wars in history, but never really considered just what this entailed. Like any horrific events that have taken place in our planet's history, it is easy to look at the Great War from a distance without ever actually considering the devastating effects it had on the people that experienced it firsthand. However, this class has given me the opportunity to get a better grasp on what exactly transpired during the years of 1914-1918. Millions of people died and those who survived were left with memories that would haunt them for the rest of their lives. Reading "Rites of War" by Eksteins made the topic that we have been discussing the first weeks of class very real to me and left many lasting images in my mind.

For my first blog, I thought I would discuss the specific things that left a mark on me from this article and see what others thought about the brutalities that took place, as well as the other interesting aspects of the war, such as the truces brought up in "Live and Let Live" or the abandonment of the army by many French soldiers. The simple fact of just how low morale was for men in the trenches was made even more apparent to me when reading the descriptions of the awful things that made up life in the trenches. Rats and other vermin, bitter cold and rain, unreliable rations, and a lack of communication between the front lines and the rest of the military made life simply miserable for those in the trenches. The gruesome details of the battlefield made it even more understandable why many people in the trenches just wanted to die. A barren wasteland littered with corpses, where everything smelled of death (a smell which permeated the trenches, even into the soldiers' rations). The blasts of artillery would stir up the earth, strewing corpses and body parts everywhere. I was particularly horrified by the story of a Frenchmen who was buried in dirt and dug himself out to see one of his comrade's torsoes sticking out of the ground nearby, only to find that it was a decomposing corpse when he tried to help him out and ripped off his head. The stories like this detailed in "Rites of War" made real to me a conflict that never really was before.

I could go on and on about the details of the Great War that have been made real to me by reading some of the articles we have the last week. I had no idea the number of innocent women and children that were killed by this war. The idea of the "total war" that Germany enacted was completely foreign to me before reading about it in-depth. Schools, churches, and centuries-old libraries were destroyed without any regard to the effects these actions might have. The combination of new technology and old warfare made for a war that saw many phases (this is another fact that I was not aware of). I am interested to see what details of this conflict we have covered so far stick out to people, and how they parallel this war to events transpiring today.

3 comments:

  1. Joe, the realistic descriptions of WWI were very shocking for me as well. Although I have learned about the horrors of trench warfare in the past, at a high school level students are more censored against some of the more intense graphic material. Despite the complications it brought to the fighting, I was very surprised about the occurrence of the "Live and Let Live" policy enacted by opposing fronts. The idea kind of gave me a sense of comfort that humanity was still acknowledged in the midst of all the inhumane violence. Also, I find myself trying to put myself in the shoes of a WWI soldier fighting in trench warfare. Overall, I could definitely see how some soldiers abandoned their troops regardless of their national loyalty.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was also struck by the the "Live and Let Live" system. I assumed that with constant artillery bombarments that it would have been easy for a soldier on one side to want to kill his enemy, especially with the national rivalries. However I feel like with the conditions that you mentioned Joe, many of the soldiers just wanted to get by. The British soldier was hungry exhausted and wet just like the German in the other trench. Their was unqiue mutual respect between soldiers that made them sympathetic towards their enemy. I think from a military stand point I dont see too many similarities between now and then. Armies can move so quickly now whether it be men or supplies and communicate so much more efficently that it aviods trench warfare all together.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The Great War often seems overshadowed by the horror of WWII but in many ways I think perhaps the warfare itself was more horrific. The great contrast that you mention between the weapons and the stactics permitted continual mass slaughter with seeming total disregard for the lives of the men. For me sometimes the hardest thing to come to grips with about WWI is how the men could stand it. Certainly the more one learns about WWI, the more one understands the tremendous psychological impact of the Great War and how it in many ways defined the 20th century.

    ReplyDelete